Skip to content
Smart Focus Zone

Should the Blacksmith Has a Million Detractors, I Stand as Among Them.

Upon learning that Clint from the beloved farming sim had been announced as one of the two marriage candidates in the forthcoming 1.7 update, I exclaimed incredulously, “That incel?!” I was fixated for the rest of the evening — if Clint has a legion of critics (and he does), count me among their ranks; were he to have no enemies, I have left the world of the living. However, after sleeping on it, I’ve come to see that perhaps this is precisely the intent — no resident in more dire need of redemption than Clint.

The Root of the Ire

Clint has drawn significant criticism for a long time, primarily because of his obsession with Emily, another eligible bachelor. During his early cutscenes, he asks the player for their advice on women, then behaves incredibly awkwardly around Emily, who is taking his order in the saloon, then laments to the player that he’s “finished.” He often appears defeatist, needy, and borderline creepy — to many, he embodies a classic “nice guy” who gets angry at the smallest perceived rejection.

A Widespread Response

My reaction to this aspect of the new update was anything but solitary. Players have voiced a myriad of complaints, sadness about other characters who could have been picked instead, and countless memes since the news dropped. One social media user wrote, “Imagine getting off a terrible day of your life and learning Clint is now a marriable character in Stardew Valley.”

A Spark of Potential

Nevertheless, some discussion on the matter offers a brighter perspective and — as much as I hate to admit it — has raised some valid arguments. Some fans have likened the prospect of reforming Clint to that of Haley. She is notoriously rude when you first meet her, but softens over time through friendship, a journey some have called “power-leveling Haley to make her better as a person.” Clint possesses much that same potential, but with one key difference: he gives a lot of players feel uncomfortable.

Screenshot: ConcernedApe

The 'Ick' Factor

I’ve personally always found Haley’s initial unpleasantness easier to stomach than Clint’s one-sided obsession with a woman who isn't interested, and many other players seem to feel that sentiment. It’s hard to place a finger on precisely why — perhaps it’s just a situation lots of people can identify with, provoking a more visceral reaction to Clint. This ick factor Clint possesses undeniably presents an extra wrinkle in him being seen as an appealing marriage candidate, but that might be yet another reason the character desperately needs redemption.

A Hint of Sympathy

It must be said that, as many times as I’ve shouted about Clint needing to stop being weird, he does inspire some level of sympathy. Maybe not during the infamous bush-hiding incident, but overall, he does seem like a sad, lonely man. As one observer noted, “Clint is someone looking for someone to reciprocate his feelings, and that is what being romanceable gives him.”

A Role for Growth

The blacksmith's upcoming relationship storyline might not appeal to all types of Stardew Valley player, but it does have its place. As dubious as I am that I could ever viewing him as spouse material, the game's creator is a skilled storyteller with a knack for giving depth to all the residents in Pelican Town. Just as with previous expansions, the new version appears as a sizable new addition crafted with care at its heart, and his character arc is surely not being done flippantly. Perhaps with Clint’s new romance future, fans can at last set aside their disdain for him aside and redirect it where it truly belongs — toward Pierre.

The writer

Kara Johnson

Cognitive psychologist specializing in attention management and productivity optimization.

Smart Focus Zone

Type to search articles.